Harry Potter’s influence reaches far beyond the sphere of providing an entertaining story for children to read. When the first book arrived here in the US there was all kinds of uproar in the christian community about its defamation of Jesus and apparent blatant attempts to sway children towards satanism and magic – I received an email from a dear church friend of mine saying so.
At the time I was still in deep in the church, a worship leader and children’s church director, but bubbles of doubt had been making their way to the surface of my conscious thought for a couple of years , instigated by my observations about the world within christianity and the world outside of it. When the email hit my inbox I read it, followed up on the links and also researched what other christian parents were saying about the book. In the end, I realized the only way I could make a reasonable decision about Harry Potter was to read the book myself.
It was a watershed moment for me. First, there was no defamation of Jesus, no promotion of Satan. There are no religious connections in the book whatsoever which means the email circulating was a complete lie and the author of the note either read the book and lied about it anyway, or didn’t read the book and decided to promote a fear-inducing story based on ignorance.
Then, I began to look at other issues the church was talking about by reading the leading publications. Instead of taking their word for it, I did the research myself. In each instance I found that the church was absolutely promoting false information and with an obvious overtone of fear. Whether or not there was a god, I made my decision to leave the church. Even HE couldn’t condone the obvious lies, I thought.
A recent article published by Christianity Today takes a look at the tornado of fear stirred up by Harry Potter and other issues and confesses that on the whole, there really is much ado about nothing. To this day I am willing to research just about anything that pops up on my facebook feed in the hopes that someone, somewhere may just get it right. Alas, there’s always more hype and subterfuge than reality reveals, and the fear inducing rhetoric is blatant as always.
I shouldn’t be surprised. The premise for converting to christianity is fear of going to hell so using fear to keep the congregation clinging to something more hopeful is of course the preferred modus operandi. What saddens me, what concerns me, what “really grinds my gears” is the blind acceptance of it all. Even the author of the CT article stops short of actually admitting that their assertions were lies. Instead he provides a short analysis on the idea that maybe the church is becoming more accepting – thereby missing the point that all the issues he exemplifies have been circulated as a means to promote fear. Whether or not Harry Potter actually affected millions of young minds didn’t matter, what mattered was successfully creating a shroud of fear and anxiety so that we couldn’t see for ourselves the reality of the issue – this was a harmless book that reiterated the same hero theme as Jesus’ own story. Sigh. Even in the admission that there’s been much ado about nothing, we are still unable to admit that fear is used as an effective tool by the church to keep its people isolated from reality.
Here’s to those who are willing to look beyond the fear.